Terrainby LegisGo

Where to build homes in Non-metro New York

Terrain ranks 444 neighborhoods in Non-metro New York on its for-sale homes model, built for homebuilders, multifamily developers and land brokers. Below: the ten that rank highest, exactly how the ranking is built, and the figures behind the top result. Data as of November 20, 2026.

The ten highest-ranked neighborhoods

  1. Scotch BushFlorida, Montgomery Co.
  2. DresdenTorrey, Yates Co.
  3. Taconic ShoresColumbia Co.
  4. Bluff PointJerusalem, Yates Co.
  5. MedwayNew Baltimore, Greene Co.
  6. ReynoldsvilleHector, Schuyler Co.
  7. ReliusAurelius, Cayuga Co.
  8. Manny CornersAmsterdam, Montgomery Co.
  9. Kauneonga LakeBethel, Sullivan Co.
  10. Lost VillageOswegatchie, St. Lawrence Co.

A neighborhood is a census tract, named for the community at its center. The ranking compares each tract with the others in Non-metro New York; it is a screen for where to look first, not a verdict on any site.

How the ranking is built

What countsShare of scoreBetter when
Homes built 2020 or laterU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–202438%higher
Permit trend, issuing officeU.S. Census Bureau Building Permits Survey, Oct 2025 – Sep 2026 vs prior 12 months23%higher
Median household incomeU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–202415%higher
Jobs within 2 milesU.S. Census Bureau, 2022 (newest year the state publishes)8%higher
Median home valueU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–20248%higher
Residents per sq miU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–20248%lower

Each input is the tract's percentile within Non-metro New York. The score is their weighted average. Subscribers can change the weights and add other indicators.

Why Scotch Bush ranks first

Scotch Bush, Florida, Montgomery Co., scores 87 of 100 and ranks first of 444 for for-sale homes. The figures a buyer reads first:

Homes built 2020 or laterU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–20241.9%93rd pct.
Median household incomeU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–2024$92,71292nd pct.
Median home valueU.S. Census Bureau, 2020–2024$203,90073rd pct.

The whole market, on the map

Shaded by the fifth of the ranking each neighborhood falls in. Click any area.

Lower to top 20%
Live data: loading the market. Click any area.Open the full map

More for Non-metro New York

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau (American Community Survey 2020–2024, LEHD LODES, County Business Patterns 2023, Building Permits Survey), CDC PLACES, HRSA, USGS place names. Figures are public records as published; Terrain ranks them and does not alter them.Terrain · Markets · LegisGo