SB1687113th GA (Historical)Introduced

Amends TCA Title 33; Title 37; Title 39; Title 40 and Title 41.

VERDICT OF GUILTY BUT MENTALLY ILL This bill provides that a defendant is guilty but mentally ill if, at the time of the commission of the act constituting the offense, the defendant had the ability to appreciate the nature or wrongfulness of the defendant's acts, but because of mental disease or defect the defendant lacked sufficient capacity to conform the defendant's conduct to the requirements of the law. To return a verdict of guilty but mentally ill, this bill provides that the burden of proof is upon the state to prove beyond a reasonable doubt to the trier of fact that the defendant committed the offense, and the burden of proof is upon the defendant to prove by a preponderance of evidence that when the defendant committed the offense the defendant was mentally ill as required by this bill. Additionally, this bill provides that the verdict of guilty but mentally ill may be rendered only during the phase of a trial that determines guilt or innocence and must not be rendered during sentencing. This bill provides that a court must not accept a plea of guilty but mentally ill unless, after a hearing on the matter, the court makes a finding upon the record that the defendant proved by a preponderance of the evidence that when the defendant committed the offense the defendant was mentally ill as required by this bill. SENTENCING This bill provides that in a prosecution for an offense when the affirmative defense of insanity is raised sufficiently by the defendant, or when sufficient evidence of a mental disease or defect of the defendant is admitted into evidence, the trier of fact must find under the applicable law, and the verdict must so state, whether the defendant is guilty; not guilty; not guilty by reason of insanity; or guilty but mentally ill. If a verdict is returned of guilty but mentally ill, the bill provides that then the defendant must be sentenced by the trial judge as provided by law for a defendant found guilty; provided, however: (1) If the sentence imposed upon the defendant includes the incarceration of the defendant, then the defendant must first be taken to a forensic services unit designated by the commissioner of mental health and substance abuse services for treatment and retained there until (i) in the opinion of the chief officer of the forensic services unit the defendant may safely be moved to a correctional facility to serve the remainder of the defendant's sentence; or (ii) the expiration of the defendant's sentence; and (2) If the sentence includes a period of probation, the judge is authorized to impose those conditions and restrictions on the release of the defendant as the judge considers necessary for the safety of the defendant and of the community. RELEASE This bill provides that if a defendant is released pursuant to this bill, then the district attorney general must immediately notify the applicable probation office, which must monitor compliance by the defendant of the terms and conditions of release. The defendant's probation officer must file quarterly reports of the defendant's compliance with the terms of release with the district attorney general, trial court, defendant's attorney, and defendant. Additionally, this bill provides that if the defendant violates any of the terms of release, then the probation officer must immediately notify the trial court, district attorney general, defendant's attorney, and defendant. Upon the receipt of the notice, the trial court, upon notice to all parties, may hold a hearing to determine whether the defendant meets the standard for judicial commitment under present law or order such other action as the court may deem appropriate.

What moved, what's on next week's agenda, new filings — every Monday, from the public record, free.

No account. Unsubscribe in one click.

Overview

VERDICT OF GUILTY BUT MENTALLY ILL This bill provides that a defendant is guilty but mentally ill if, at the time of the commission of the act constituting the offense, the defendant had the ability to appreciate the nature or wrongfulness of the defendant's acts, but because of mental disease or defect the defendant lacked sufficient capacity to conform the defendant's conduct to the requirements of the law. To return a verdict of guilty but mentally ill, this bill provides that the burden of proof is upon the state to prove beyond a reasonable doubt to the trier of fact that the defendant committed the offense, and the burden of proof is upon the defendant to prove by a preponderance of evidence that when the defendant committed the offense the defendant was mentally ill as required by this bill. Additionally, this bill provides that the verdict of guilty but mentally ill may be rendered only during the phase of a trial that determines guilt or innocence and must not be rendered during sentencing. This bill provides that a court must not accept a plea of guilty but mentally ill unless, after a hearing on the matter, the court makes a finding upon the record that the defendant proved by a preponderance of the evidence that when the defendant committed the offense the defendant was mentally ill as required by this bill. SENTENCING This bill provides that in a prosecution for an offense when the affirmative defense of insanity is raised sufficiently by the defendant, or when sufficient evidence of a mental disease or defect of the defendant is admitted into evidence, the trier of fact must find under the applicable law, and the verdict must so state, whether the defendant is guilty; not guilty; not guilty by reason of insanity; or guilty but mentally ill. If a verdict is returned of guilty but mentally ill, the bill provides that then the defendant must be sentenced by the trial judge as provided by law for a defendant found guilty; provided, however: (1) If the sentence imposed upon the defendant includes the incarceration of the defendant, then the defendant must first be taken to a forensic services unit designated by the commissioner of mental health and substance abuse services for treatment and retained there until (i) in the opinion of the chief officer of the forensic services unit the defendant may safely be moved to a correctional facility to serve the remainder of the defendant's sentence; or (ii) the expiration of the defendant's sentence; and (2) If the sentence includes a period of probation, the judge is authorized to impose those conditions and restrictions on the release of the defendant as the judge considers necessary for the safety of the defendant and of the community. RELEASE This bill provides that if a defendant is released pursuant to this bill, then the district attorney general must immediately notify the applicable probation office, which must monitor compliance by the defendant of the terms and conditions of release. The defendant's probation officer must file quarterly reports of the defendant's compliance with the terms of release with the district attorney general, trial court, defendant's attorney, and defendant. Additionally, this bill provides that if the defendant violates any of the terms of release, then the probation officer must immediately notify the trial court, district attorney general, defendant's attorney, and defendant. Upon the receipt of the notice, the trial court, upon notice to all parties, may hold a hearing to determine whether the defendant meets the standard for judicial commitment under present law or order such other action as the court may deem appropriate.

Track Tennessee Legislation Like a Pro

Join hundreds of professionals using LegisGo to stay ahead of legislative changes.

Instant Alerts

Get notified when bills you track move through the legislature

AI Summaries

Understand complex legislation in seconds with AI-powered analysis

Full Access

All 132 legislators, committee schedules, and voting records

Sponsor

Unknown

Details
Session

113th General Assembly

Introduced

January 9, 2024

Subjects
12153805314031351065

Want to track this bill? Get instant alerts and AI-powered insights.